Actus reus: Perbezaan antara semakan

A number of offences are defined as a situation or context, e.g., "being found within enclosed premises" and "being drunk in charge of a motor vehicle". These are usually strict liability and a conviction can be sustained even though an accused did not act in a wholly voluntary manner. Hence, if a person falls asleep in a quiet corner of a library and is locked in by inadvertent staff, the offence will be committed, but the relatively low level of fault could be reflected in the sentence. In ''Martin v State'' (1944) 31 Ala App 334 17 So 2d 427. Martin was arrested at home and taken onto the highway by police officers, where he showed signs of being drunk. His conviction for being drunk on a public highway was quashed because his arrival on the highway was not voluntary. Whereas in ''R v Larsonneur'' (1933) 24 Cr. App. R. 74 Larsonneur, a French citizen, was served with an order requiring her to leave the UK and not return. Instead of returning to France, she travelled to Ireland, and was deported back to England where she was arrested for "being found in the United Kingdom". The Court of Criminal Appeal held that the involuntary circumstances under which she was returned were "perfectly immaterial". In ''Winzar v Chief Constable of Kent'' (1983) The Times, 28 March 1983. where the charge was one of being "found drunk on a highway" contrary to s12 Licensing Act 1872, Winzar had originally been found drunk in a hospital and asked to leave. When he failed to do so, police officers removed him to their patrol car, which was parked on the highway outside, and then charged him with the offence in question. Upholding the conviction, Goff LJ. pointed out that a distinction would otherwise have to be drawn between the drunk who leaves a restaurant when asked to do so and the drunk who is forcibly ejected after refusing to leave. If both are arrested in the street shortly afterwards, it would be wrong for the courts to regard the former as guilty and the latter as not. But the U.S. approach of [[abuse of process]] might prevail if the police were to drag a person from his own bed and into the street before charging him with being found drunk on a highway.

 

¹ Coke's ''Institutes'', Part III (1797 edition) chapter 1, folio 10.

 

{{Undang-undang}}

 

 

[[de:Tatbestand]]