Penyembelihan Sabra dan Shatila: Perbezaan antara semakan
Kandungan dihapus Kandungan ditambah
Tiada ringkasan suntingan |
Tiada ringkasan suntingan |
||
Baris 37:
Sesetengah, seperti [[Noam Chomsky]] dan [[Robert Fisk]], telah menuduh bahawa Israil sudah pastinya sedar tentang penyembelihan tersebut. Tambahan lagi, mereka mempertikaikan terdapatnya sebarang anggota PLO dalam kawasan kem, kerana (1) dakwaan Kahan Commission bahawa IDF menghantar 150 [[Phalangist]] untuk melawan 2,000 ahli PLO (ciri-ciri taktik ketenteraan lemah) dan (2) [[Phalangist]] mengalami hanya 2 kematian, sesuatu yang mustahil selepas pertempuran 36-jam melawan 2,000 tentera berpengalaman [FT]. Analisa Chomsky telah di kritik oleh penyokong Israil sebagai subjektif, disebabkan oleh pandanga politiknya yang diakui olehnya sendiri, yang dianggap which are considered radical by many. Both books have been critically acclaimed.
Some, such as [[Noam Chomsky]] and [[Robert Fisk]], have alleged that the Israelis must have been aware of the massacre. Furthermore, they have doubted that there were any PLO members in the camps, as (1) the Kahan Commission claims that the IDF sent 150 Phalangists to fight 2,000 PLO members (an uncharacteristically poor military tactic) and (2) the Phalangists suffered only two casualties, an impropable outcome of a 36-hour battle involving 2,000 experienced soldiers [FT]. Chomsky's analysis has been criticized by some as subjective, due to his own, proclaimed political views, which are considered radical by many. Both books have been critically acclaimed.
| |||